The best AI stock trading software depends on which part of your trading process you want to improve. Finding a setup, testing a strategy, interpreting an earnings call, and placing an order are different jobs. A platform that excels at one may need another service to complete the others.
My independent lab tests show TrendSpider has world-class AI pattern recognition, backtesting, LLMs, and auto-trading. Trade Ideas has the best AI-powered high-probability day-trading signals. TradingView enables live bot trading and broker integration, with a chatbot and MCP server integration.
Best AI Stock Trading Tools Ratings & Comparison
Our overall scores cover the wider platform. The AI & Algo category assesses algorithmic capabilities, the AI layer, and transparency. Keeping the two separate explains why a highly rated charting platform may not lead this particular comparison.
| Platform | Overall platform rating | AI & Algo lab rating | How I use it | What it does |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TrendSpider AI ↓ Lab test | Review | 4.72 | 5.00 | Developing strategies and AI-assisted research | Custom predictive models, Sidekick research, strategy testing and alerts |
| Trade Ideas ↓ Lab test | Review | 4.52 | 4.50 | Finding US stock day-trading setups | Holly AI generates trade ideas with entry and risk information |
| TradingView ↓ Lab test | Review | 4.75 | 4.00 | Charting, connected AI research and explicit strategies | Pine Script, backtesting, webhook alerts and an official MCP server |
| Seeking Alpha ↓ Lab test | Review | 4.35 | 4.00 | Fundamental quant research and investment-thesis evaluation | Ask Seeking Alpha, Virtual Analyst Reports, Earnings Call Insights and Quant ratings |
| MetaStock ↓ Lab test | Review | 4.42 | 2.50 | Detailed historical system testing | Rule-based analysis, forecasting tools and strategy evaluation |
| Tickeron ↓ Lab test | Review | 4.19 | 3.50 | Exploring predefined AI models and signals | AI-generated trading ideas, patterns, and model-based strategies |
I also evaluate SignalStack, Unusual Whales, and Interactive Brokers separately. They contribute to execution, options-flow research, or brokerage-connected AI, but they have not yet received an official LST lab rating.
I have brought together our published lab tests and practical guides to explain what each platform actually does, where automation begins, and what you need to pay for. The ratings measure software capabilities; they are not a forecast of trading returns.
Need another part of the workflow? See 3 New AI Tools: Evaluated but Not Lab-Tested for SignalStack, Unusual Whales, and Interactive Brokers.
AI Lab Test Summary
- TrendSpider: Best AI Bot Pattern Recognition & Backtesting
- Trade Ideas: Best Automated Stock Trading Bot
- TradingView: Global AI Stock & Crypto Bot Trading
- Seeking Alpha: Deep Human Research Parsed by AI Chatbots
My lab research identifies TrendSpider and Trade Ideas as the leaders in AI trading software. Trade Ideas offers automated trading and bots, while TrendSpider offers personal LLMs, automated pattern recognition, auto-trading, and backtesting.
Rules-based AI and day-trading Bot platforms are becoming pervasive. Machine learning and deep learning are growing fast.TrendSpider leads the pack, using AI for automated technical analysis and backtesting, as well as Agentic AI and custom LLMs, to significantly improve human chart analysis. Trade Ideas consists of three advanced high-performing AI algorithms, broker integration, and auto-trading. Trading recently introduced an MCP server and chatbot assistance, which propels it up the rankings.
| Top Rated AI Trading Tools | TrendSpider | Trade Ideas | TradingView | Seeking Alpha |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AI Software Rating | 5.00 | 4.50 | 4.00 | 4.00 |
| AI Trading Signals | ✔ | ✔ | X | X |
| AI Pattern Recognition | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | X |
| Auto-Trading Bots & Webhooks | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | X |
| Chat Bot Assistance | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ |
| MCP Server (Model Context Protocol) | ✔ Agentic AI | X | ✔ | X |
| Try It | TrendSpider | Trade Ideas | TradingView | Seeking Alpha |
Table 1: AI Trading Software Comparison Table & Ratings
AI Chatbots, Webhooks and MCP: Which Tools Support Them?
These features solve different problems. A chatbot gives you a conversational interface. A webhook sends a message when an event occurs. An MCP server lets a compatible AI assistant access authorized data and perform actions. Having one does not imply that a platform supports the others—or that it can trade without supervision.
| Tool | Chatbot or conversational assistant | Bot Webhooks | Official MCP server |
|---|---|---|---|
| TrendSpider | Yes: Sidekick research assistant | Yes: outgoing alert and strategy-bot messages | Agentic AI |
| Trade Ideas | Research chatbot not verified; Holly supplies signals | No | No |
| Tickeron | No | No | No |
| TradingView | Support chatbot; AI research and charting conversations | Yes: outgoing alert messages | Yes: public MCP for Essential and above; trials excluded |
| Seeking Alpha | Yes: Ask Seeking Alpha | No | No |
| MetaStock | No | No | No |
| SignalStack | No | Yes: receives messages and routes supported orders | No |
| Unusual Whales | Yes: Mr. Whale | Discord notifications & webhooks | Yes: official market-data integration |
| Interactive Brokers | Yes: Ask IBKR; IBot supports natural-language platform commands | Via an external bridge such as SignalStack | Yes: official account-connected integration |
Feature references: TradingView MCP, TradingView support chatbot, TradingView webhooks, TrendSpider bots, Ask Seeking Alpha, SignalStack webhooks, Unusual Whales MCP, Unusual Whales notification webhooks, and IBKR AI integrations.
What Does AI Stock Trading Software Actually Do?
“AI trading bot” can describe several quite different products. Before subscribing, establish which of these functions you are buying:
- A research assistant interprets information or helps you operate the platform. TrendSpider Sidekick or Ask Seeking Alpha are good examples.
- A predictive model learns relationships from training data and produces an output for a defined task. That output might help identify a setup; it does not establish that the next trade will succeed.
- A signal service supplies trade ideas for you to evaluate. Holly is an example of receiving a provider’s signals rather than building your own model.
- An execution service submits orders when specified conditions are met. SignalStack performs this connecting role.
Algorithmic trading is broader than AI. A strategy that buys when one moving average crosses another follows explicit rules, even if it runs automatically. A machine-learning model derives relationships from data, but it still needs a defined objective, evaluation, and a separate process for placing trades.
I explain these distinctions further in my guide to AI trading strategies. They matter because you can buy excellent analysis software and still end up with no working automated trading system.
How I Evaluated These Platforms
This comparison uses the published LST lab assessments linked above, and the practical examples in my related guides. I focus on four questions: What task does the tool perform? What output can you inspect? How much control do you retain? What additional setup is necessary?
Our lab scores help answer those questions. They do not establish that one platform profits more than another. Nor have I treated vendor backtests, simulated accounts, or selected winning trades as independently verified live performance.
1. TrendSpider: My #1 Choice for a Complete AI Toolset, LLMs, Chatbot & Agentic AI
TrendSpider is my AI tool of choice; it brings several stages of the research process into a single platform, and its AI tools serve different purposes. ML Quant Lab, formerly AI Strategy Lab, is for developing predictive models. Sidekick is an assistant for research and working with the platform. Strategy testing, alerts, and trade execution are knitted together in a slick workflow.
TrendSpider received the strongest AI & Algo score across all lab tests. I particularly value the choice between developing a model and using an assistant to investigate information. These are useful at different stages of a research session.
That combination is particularly useful if you want to investigate your own idea. For example, you might explore whether a defined combination of price behavior and indicators helps identify a particular setup. The important decision is what you want the model to predict, followed by how you will judge whether its output is useful.
Connectivity: Chatbot: Sidekick. Webhooks: outgoing alerts and strategy bots, and full agentic AI built in.
| ⚡ Features | Charts, Watchlists, Screening, Free Real-time Data |
| 🏆 Unique Features | AI-Automated Trendlines, Fibonacci, Candlestick Pattern Recognition, Auto-Bot Trading, Code-free, Powerful Backtesting, Launch and Train Personal AI Models with ML Quant Lab. |
| 🎯 Best for | Stock, Options, FX & Crypto Traders |
| ♲ Subscription | Monthly, Yearly |
| 💰 Price | $54 | $214 |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser |
| 🎮 Trial | ❌ |
| ✂ Discount | Code "LST30" for 30% to 63% Off |
| 🌎 Region | USA |
Save 45% on All TrendSpider Plans
Our 4.72 ⭐ Rated Trading Tool
✅ Automated Charts & Research
✅ AI Benchmark Winner
Deal Ends In:
Labtest Results: AI & Algo Rating 5.00
TrendSpider scores a perfect AAA 5.00, well above the median of 2.00. The lab framing here is: does AI/algorithmic intelligence materially improve decision workflows with enough transparency and practical utility?
In my audit notes, TrendSpider’s edge is that the AI/automation layer is not an add-on; it’s central to the workflow (strategy lab, automated reasoning overlays, execution bridge). That is why it reaches the maximum 5.00 where many tools top out as “strong algorithms, no AI layer.”
| Metric | Calculation | TrendSpider | High | Median | Low |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Algorithmic Intelligence & AI Tier Index | Sum of Algo Depth, AI Layer & Transparency points | 5.00 | 5.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
| Algo Depth | 0.5 alerts only; 1.0 rules strategies; 1.5 backtesting+factor/portfolio rules; 2.0 advanced quant platform | 2.00 | 2.00 | 1.50 | 1.00 |
| AI Layer | 0.0 none; 1.0 assistive; 1.5 ML signals core; 2.0 AI-native decisioning | 2.00 | 2.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| Transparency | 0.0 black-box; 0.5 some; 1.0 clear methodology + validation artifacts | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.00 |
| AI & Algo Index Test Winners | TrendSpider 5.00 | Trade Ideas 4.50 |
SideKick AI Chatbot
Sidekick is the chatbot engine built into TrendSpider; it can do everything from summarizing the macro environment to detailing SEC filings or analyst rating changes, even interpreting earnings calls. By summarizing earnings call transcripts and extracting key themes, Sidekick enables investors to focus on the signal rather than the noise. Used correctly, it can dramatically improve efficiency, consistency, and depth of analysis.
There is a concrete example in my earnings-call AI analysis article. After listening to an AMD earnings call, I used Sidekick to examine management’s tone and the discussion’s emotional trajectory. That gave me another interpretation to compare with my own reading.
The practical benefit is having a starting point for deeper questions. Did management explain a change in guidance? Did the Q&A reveal a concern that the prepared remarks avoided? An assistant can help direct attention, while the transcript and financial disclosures remain the evidence.
ML Quant Lab
I tested TrendSpider’s ML Quant Lab, and wow—it completely changed the way I trade! With its advanced AI tools, I could analyze multiple indicators and timeframes simultaneously, giving me a clearer, more detailed view of the market. Plus, it saved me hours I used to spend backtesting strategies manually under different conditions.
But here’s the real game-changer: the ability to create custom trading algorithms. This feature lets me craft strategies tailored perfectly to my trading style. The flexibility and control were next-level, helping me fine-tune my strategies with laser-like precision. If you’re serious about trading smarter, this tool is a total must-try!
AI Charts & Backtesting
TrendSpider offers fully automated AI-driven trendlines, Fibonacci analysis, and multi-timeframe analysis for stocks, forex, crypto, and futures. Add a robust backtesting engine, and you have a great AI technical analysis platform.
TrendSpider takes a different approach to backtesting. The platform is built from the ground up to automatically detect trendlines and Fibonacci patterns; it already includes backtesting built into its code.
The highest-probability trendlines are automatically flagged, and you can adjust the algorithm’s sensitivity to control how many lines are detected.
TrendSpider has also implemented a strategy tester that lets you freely enter what you want to test, and it will handle the coding for you. It is a smooth and simple implementation that had me up and running in minutes.
Integrated backtesting of automated trendlines, showing win rate, profitability, and drawdown, is a welcome addition; the team propels TrendSpider into one of the industry’s leading technical analysis packages.
They have also implemented an AI assistant that lets you freely type what you want to test, and it handles the coding for you.
My recommendation: Choose TrendSpider when you want to investigate ideas and develop repeatable, unique strategies. TrendSpider is currently the most well-rounded and powerful AI workflow in the industry.
Compare TrendSpider pricing and discounts · See the TrendSpider lab evidence
2. Trade Ideas: My Choice for AI-Powered Stock Day Trading Signals
Trade Ideas is the leading AI trading software for identifying real-time day-trading opportunities. Trade Ideas has three cutting-edge AI stock-trading bots that backtest all US stocks in real time to identify high-probability trading opportunities.
Connectivity: Research chatbot: not verified. General-purpose trading webhooks: not verified. Official MCP server: not verified. Brokerage Plus provides a separate broker-integration workflow.
| ⚡ Features | Charts, Watchlists, Screening |
| 🏆 Unique Features | AI Trade Signals, Trading Room, Trading Competitions |
| 🎯 Best for | Active US stock traders who use scans and alerts throughout the session |
| ♲ Subscription | Monthly, Yearly |
| 💰 Price* | $89 | $178 |
| 🆓 Free Version | ✔ |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser, PC |
| 🎮 Trial | Free Live Trading Room |
| ✂ Discount | -15% Discount Code "LIBERATED" |
| 🌎 Region | USA |
| Why choose Premium? | Holly AI, backtesting, and auto-trading capabilities |
*Price is the annual plan monthly equivalent
Save 28% on Trade Ideas Premium
Our 4.52 ⭐ Rated AI-Day Trading Tool
☆ Code "HOLLYOCT28" ☆
Deal Ends In:
Trade Ideas is the more natural starting point when your question is, “Which US stocks have actionable setups today?” Its Holly service supplies trade ideas with entry and risk information, giving you defined opportunities to investigate.
The distinction from TrendSpider matters. With Holly, you are evaluating a provider’s signals. You are not choosing a training dataset and building a custom predictive model from the ground up.
My Trade Ideas review examines the signal workflow and wider platform in more detail. For this comparison, the key benefit lies in how a proposed trade is presented: an entry is only useful when you can also understand the exit logic and potential losses.
Lab Test: AI & Algo 4.50
The AI algorithms developed by Trade Ideas are the main reason you want to sign up. This company is laser-focused on providing traders with the best data-supported trading opportunities. There are currently three AI systems in operation that apply over 70 different strategies.
Trade Ideas earns 4.50 vs 2.00 median, one of the widest gaps in the entire benchmark set. In practical terms, it is not simply a scanner with “AI marketing.” It is built around AI-driven strategy generation and signal delivery (Holly AI is positioned as a core premium feature).
This is consistent with Trade Ideas’ market positioning: “AI-driven strategies and signals” are sold as a premium layer.
| Test | Calculation | Trade Ideas | High | Median | Low |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Algorithmic Intelligence & AI Tier Index | Sum of Algo Depth, AI Layer & Transparency Points | 4.50 | 5.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
| Algo Depth | Algo Depth (0.0–2.0) | 2 | 2.00 | 1.50 | 1.0 |
| AI Layer | AI Layer (0.0–2.0) | 1.5 | 2.00 | 0.00 | 0.0 |
| Transparency | Transparency (0.0–1.0) | 1 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.0 |
| AI & Algo Index Test Winners | TrendSpider 5.00 | Trade Ideas 4.50 |
Holly AI Bots
The Holly AI stock bot is the original incarnation of their AI algorithms. Holly applies 70 different AI strategies to all the US stock exchanges; 70 strategies multiplied by 8,000+ stocks mean millions of backtests daily. Only strategies with a backtested win rate over 60% and an estimated risk-reward ratio of 2:1 will be suggested as potential trades the following day.
Holly 2.0 is a newer version of the Holly AI Bot that presents more aggressive day-trading scenarios. Trade Ideas operates three key trading strategies with its AI Stock Bot: Conservative, Moderate, and Aggressive. According to my research, Holly 2.0 is the most aggressive stock-trading bot and delivers the best returns at 33% annually.
Holly NEO is Trade Ideas’ latest AI day-trading bot. It seeks to trade real-time chart patterns and uses a mix of key day-trading technical analysis strategies, such as trading stock price pullbacks and breakouts, either long or short.
- Pullback Long: This strategy seeks to identify trades in which the stock price is down and is starting to move up on higher volume.
- Breakout Long: When the stock price breaks out through a key resistance level or reaches new highs.
- Pullback Short: identifying a short pullback opportunity in price.
- Breakdown Short: A shorting opportunity where upward momentum breaks down.
Buy & Sell Signals
A significant benefit of Trade Ideas is that it visually shows you every buy and sell signal on a chart. I have highlighted a trade Holly AI (Holly Grail) recommended in the chart below. This trade in Cleveland Biolabs (Ticker: CBLI) generated a 25% profit in 4 hours. Note how the buy and sell signals are depicted on the chart.
Automated Stock Trading
Trade Ideas is one of the few services that offer fully end-to-end automated AI stock trading. It lets you connect to eTrade or Interactive Brokers to execute trades automatically. Trade signals generated by Holly AI cannot be autotraded. Still, alert window scans can be automatically executed in a sandbox or a live environment with your brokerage using Brokerage Plus (available on the premium plan).
My Trade Ideas AI Testing
After testing the Trade Ideas platform and assessing the AI stock-trading and day-trading Bot performance, I can say this is the most compelling application of stock market AI for retail investors available today. This AI stock picker produces 3 to 10 trades daily, each lasting 2 minutes to 3 hours.
My recommendation: Choose Trade Ideas if you actively trade US stocks and want defined AI-generated setups. Premium/Apex is the relevant subscription for Holly; confirm the execution requirements before paying for an automated workflow.
Compare Trade Ideas pricing and discounts · Read my full Trade Ideas review
3. TradingView: My Choice Global Trading: Chatbot & MCP Server Access
TradingView is the most developed and highly automated platform for international stock, FX, and Crypto traders. It automatically detects chart patterns and candlestick patterns and enables AI Bot trading with Webhooks. Add to that the new Copilot Chat assistance and a new Model Context Protocol MCP server, and TradingView is propelled to spot three in our AI rankings.
Connectivity: Chatbot: support assistant, plus research conversations through an external AI assistant. Webhooks: outgoing alert messages. Official MCP server: available in public beta.
| ⚡ TradingView Features | Charts, News, Watchlists, Screening, Chart Pattern & Candlestick Recognition, Full Broker Integration |
| 🏆 Unique Features | Trading, Backtesting, Community, Global Stock, FX & Crypto Markets, Webhook Bot Integration |
| 🎯 Best for | Stock, FX & Crypto Traders |
| ♲ Subscription | Monthly, Yearly |
| 💰 Price | $0 | $15 | $35 | $70 See Pricing Guide |
| 🆓 Free | ✔ |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser|PC|IOS|Android |
| 🎮 Trial | Yes, Free 30-Day Premium |
| ✂ Discount | -17% on yearly plan + $15 Discount |
| 🌎 Region | Global |
Get Your 80% TradingView Black Friday Discount Now
Our 4.8 ⭐ Rated Winning Trading Tool
✅ Applies to New & Existing Customers
✅ Global Markets, Trading & Community
✅ Best In Class Charting
Deal Ends In:
Lab Test: AI & Algo rating: 4.00
TradingView now has a more prominent place in AI comparisons. Its charting, Pine Script, and strategy-testing tools can sit alongside a conversational research workflow with AI Copilot, and agentic actions through its official MCP server. The connection exposes screening, watchlist, document, and alert functions to a compatible assistant.
TradingView scored A 4.00 (High: 5.00 | Median: 2.00 | Low: 1.0). This category intentionally separates algorithmic capability from AI-native decisioning.
Context: TradingView is an algorithmic sandbox and scripting ecosystem. It’s excellent for building, testing, and refining logic. It is not positioned as a “black box AI that tells you what to buy.” However, the latest updates include an MCP server to connect your AI service and a chatbot called AI Copilot, integrated directly into TradingView.
| Metric | Calculation | TradingView Score | High | Median | Low |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Algorithmic Intelligence & AI Tier Index | Sum of Algo Depth, AI Layer, Transparency Points | 4.00 | 5.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
| Algo Depth | 0.5 alerts only; 1.0 rules strategies; 1.5 backtesting+factor; 2.0 advanced quant platform | 2.00 | 2.00 | 1.50 | 0.00 |
| AI Layer | 0.0 none; 1.0 assistive; 1.5 ML signals core; 2.0 AI-native decisioning | 1.00 | 2.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| Transparency | 0.0 black-box; 0.5 some; 1.0 clear methodology + validation | 1.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.00 |
A useful workflow would be to ask the assistant to screen a defined group of stocks, explain the selection criteria, and save candidates for further inspection. I would then review the charts and source information before deciding whether a setup meets my rules. This is a suggested workflow, not a claim that I have completed a new live-trading test of the beta.
TradingView Algo & Automations
TradingView can automatically detect and scan hundreds of chart patterns, including double tops and rectangles, as well as bullish and bearish candlestick patterns such as Harami, Doji, and Marubozu. This feature enhances the platform’s usability and empowers users with comprehensive market analysis tools.
The attraction is connecting research to the workspace where I already inspect charts and manage alerts. It can reduce the manual steps between a research question and a list of candidates to examine. A conversational interface is particularly useful when I want a comparison rather than another page of disconnected numbers.
TradingView also retains the advantage of explicit Pine Script rules. I can examine the conditions behind a strategy separately from an assistant’s explanation. A fluent response is useful context; the actual entry and exit logic still needs to be inspectable.
To use Pine Script backtesting, you must learn the basics of scripting, which can take some time. There is no code-free backtesting or indicator development engine.
Although not a coder, I’ve leveraged TradingView to develop my Market Outperforming Stock & ETF System (MOSES). MOSES effectively identifies potential stock market declines and opportune moments to reinvest.
AI Copilot Chat
I recently tested the newly released Copilot chatbot, and it seems quite capable. A full LLM trained on market data and community ideas and strategies is a great addition to its AI features. Worth noting, the AI Chatbot costs an extra $7.50 per month.
MCP Server
The TradingView Model Context Protocol (MCP) server acts as a dynamic bridge between AI assistants and live financial analysis, enabling models like Claude to seamlessly interact with real-time market data, technical indicators, custom Pine Scripts, and automated strategy backtests. By transforming TradingView’s chart states, indicator signals, and market metrics into structured, machine-readable formats, it empowers traders and researchers to conduct multi-timeframe technical analysis, execute precise, data-driven backtesting, and create automated watchlist briefings—all via natural language prompts in a single conversation.
TradingView AI Bot Webhook Integration
Enabling AI Bot integration on TradingView is easy: Right-click a chart, select “Add Alert,” Click “Notifications,” and add a Webhook URL. (See my screenshot image below.)
One noteworthy advantage of TradingView is its extensive selection of integrated Brokers. No matter where you are located, you can find a reputable and authorized broker to execute trades on your behalf seamlessly. Creating an alert is also different from placing an order. TradingView’s webhooks send messages to an external endpoint; a suitable execution service must interpret them and submit the intended orders.
My recommendation: Choose TradingView if you want robust charting, inspectable strategies, and integrated AI research. Test the MCP workflow against its current data and access limits, and budget separately for any execution bridge.
Compare TradingView plans and pricing · See the TradingView lab test.
4. Seeking Alpha: Best for AI-Powered Long-Term Investing Research
Seeking Alpha earns a place among the leading tested platforms because its AI can help with investment research and short-term trading signals. Its role is to help investigate a company, compare competing arguments, and decide which questions need more attention before committing capital.
Connectivity: Chatbot: Ask Seeking Alpha & Research, Assistant
| ⚡ Seeking Alpha Features ? | Charting, Pre-built Screeners, Live Webinars, Community |
| 🏆 Unique Features ? | Alpha Picks Winning Track Record, Quant Ratings, Top Analysts with Audited Performance, New AI ChatBot & AI Research Assistant |
| 🎯 Best for | Stock & ETF Investors |
| ♲ Subscription | Yearly |
| 💰 Price | $24 | $41/m |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser |
| 🎮 Trial | 7 Day Premium Trial |
| ✂ Discount | -21% Alpha Picks & Premium Bundle |
| 🌎 Region | USA |
Lab Test: AI & Algo 4.00
Seeking Alpha scores 4.00, above the median 2.00. The nuance: it earns this via algorithmic depth + transparency + a new AI Chatbot and Virtual AI Analyst. The addition of a ChatBot and an AI-powered virtual analyst has propelled Seeking Alpha to become a stock research leader by leveraging AI to parse the depth of its proprietary analyst research.
| Metric | Calculation | Seeking Alpha | High | Median | Low |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Algorithmic Intelligence & AI Tier Index | Sum of Algo Depth, AI Layer & Transparency Points | 4.00 | 5.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
| Algo Depth | Algo Depth | 2.00 | 2.00 | 1.50 | 1.00 |
| AI Layer | AI Layer | 1.50 | 2.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| Transparency | Transparency | 0.50 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 0.00 |
| AI & Algo Index Test Winners | TrendSpider 5.00 | Trade Ideas 4.50 |
In Context: AI & Algo scores only matter if they change decisions. Seeking Alpha’s advantage is systematic evaluation: you’re not relying solely on vibes, headlines, or a single analyst’s conviction.
Ask Seeking Alpha
Ask Seeking Alpha provides a conversational way to explore the platform’s financial information, ratings and analysis. It sits alongside tools such as Virtual Analyst Reports and Earnings Call Insights. These serve different needs: an interactive question, a structured stock overview and a quicker review of a company’s earnings discussion.
I value the ability to turn a broad investment idea into specific questions. For example, I would ask what supports a company’s earnings outlook, which assumptions appear most vulnerable, and how the bullish argument compares with the bearish case. Those questions help me identify evidence to check in filings and management commentary.
This complements the process in my earnings-call analysis guide: use an assistant to direct attention, then return to the underlying statements and financial results. A summary is most useful when it helps locate a consequential issue that deserves closer reading.
Seeking Alpha’s Quant ratings provide another viewpoint, but I keep the rating framework separate from the chatbot. A numerical ranking and a generated explanation are different outputs. Agreement between them is a reason to investigate the supporting evidence, rather than an automatic instruction to buy.
My recommendation: Choose Seeking Alpha for AI-assisted company research and investment-thesis evaluation. It is especially relevant when your holding period gives you time to investigate a business, compare arguments, and monitor whether the original thesis still holds.
Read my Seeking Alpha review · See the Seeking Alpha lab test · Compare Seeking Alpha plans.
5. MetaStock: Algo-Driven Backtesting, Forecasting & Expert Advisors
MetaStock has good algorithmic backtesting and forecasting capabilities. It is a stock market technical analysis and charting service with over 600 chart types and indicators. MetaStock allows the charting of stocks, ETFs, indices, bonds, and currencies.
Connectivity: The historical testing tools and forecasting algorithms are the main reasons for its inclusion here.
| ⚡ Features | Charts, Watchlists, Scanning, Backtesting |
| 🏆 Unique Features | Algorithmic AI Forecasting, Real-time Global Trading News (Multi-language), Candle Pattern Recognition. |
| 🎯 Best for | Stock, FX & Commodity Traders |
| ♲ Subscription | Monthly, Yearly |
| 💰 Price | $75|$100|$265 |
| 💻 OS | PC |
| 🎮 Trial | 30-Day Free Trial |
| ✂ Discount | 3 Months for the Price of 1 (worth $530) |
| 🌎 Region | Global |
Save Up to 60% in MetaStock's Cyber Sale Now
Our Top Rated Global Real-Time News Technical Analysis Tool
✅ 60% Off MetaStock 20 Upgrades
✅ 60% Off Add-Ons
Deal Ends In:
MetaStock is relevant to this comparison because forecasting, systematic analysis, and AI are often grouped in trading software marketing. Its stronger case lies in the depth of its analytical and historical testing tools.
A forecast or an Expert Advisor label does not, by itself, establish machine learning or automatic broker execution. The linked lab assessment treats MetaStock’s algorithmic capabilities separately from an AI-native signal engine.
What I Like: Backtesting 4.81
The backtesting result supports considering MetaStock when evaluating trading systems. I value being able to investigate an idea before deciding whether it belongs in a live workflow. When the exchange data is local, backtesting and forecasting are blazing fast.
A useful research question is whether a strategy’s apparent advantage survives different assumptions and periods. That is more informative than selecting the most attractive historical result and assuming it will continue.
Lab Test: AI & Algo 2.50
AI & Algo Index distinguishes algorithmic depth (rules, models, backtests), the presence of a true AI layer, and transparency. This matters because “AI” claims are common; what traders need is repeatable value and explainability.
MetaStock scores 2.50, above the Median (2.00), largely due to strong algorithmic depth and transparency, while the AI layer itself is not a core feature in the benchmark sense.
| Metric | What It Measures | Calculation | MetaStock | High | Median | Low |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Algorithmic Intelligence & AI Tier Index | Overall AI/algo tier | Algo depth + AI + transparency | 2.50 | 5.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
| Algo Depth | Strategy/model depth | 0–2 rubric | 1.5 | 2.0 | 1.5 | 1.0 |
| AI Layer | AI presence | 0–2 rubric | 0.0 | 2.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| Transparency | Explainability | 0–1 rubric | 1.0 | 1.0 | 1.0 | 0.0 |
| AI & Algo Index Test Winners | TrendSpider 5.00 | Trade Ideas 4.50 |
MetaStock’s AI & Algo result is lower than those of the AI specialists, with no AI-layer points awarded in the published audit. Its testing capabilities are not equivalent to those of a modern research assistant or a custom machine-learning environment.
Execution is also a limitation: the audit did not identify native broker execution. Budget and choose your workflow accordingly.
Another area where MetaStock excels is its “Expert Advisors.” MetaStock’s Expert Advisors are Trading Bots designed to help you understand and profit from technical analysis patterns and supply-and-demand fluctuations as a beginner or intermediate trader. These algorithms are not as advanced as the stock market AI provided by Trade Ideas, but you can improve upon them with a little coding knowledge.
My recommendation: Consider MetaStock when historical system research is your priority. Check the edition, data subscription, and any additional tools you need before comparing the total cost with that of an AI-focused platform.
Compare MetaStock pricing · Read the MetaStock lab test.
6. Tickeron: Explore Predefined AI Models
Tickeron is a solid AI trading platform that uses stock chart pattern recognition to predict future trends and provides 45 streams of trading ideas. Tickeron lets you build AI portfolios with predictive returns.
Tickeron’s AI & Algo score makes it a credible candidate for readers interested in predefined models. A useful exercise is to compare the model’s intended task with your own trading horizon and process.
For example, before following a model, write down the instruments it covers, the expected holding period, and the action its output is supposed to trigger. This gives you a consistent way to evaluate subsequent signals rather than reacting to whichever example seems most persuasive.
Connectivity: AI portfolios and AI backtested trading strategies, with real-time pattern recognition.
| ⚡ Tickeron Features | Portfolios, Watchlists, Screening, 45 Streams of Trade Ideas |
| 🏆 Unique Features | Real-time AI Trading Signals for ETF, Forex & Crypto & Pattern Recognition, AI Portfolios |
| 🎯 Best for | Day & Swing Traders |
| ♲ Subscription | Monthly, Yearly |
| 💰 Price | $0 | $250 | $125 |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser, PC |
| 🎮 Trial | 14-Day Free Trial |
| ✂ Discount | 50% Discount on Yearly Plan |
| 🌎 Region | USA |
Lab Test: AI & Algo 3.50
This is Tickeron’s flagship: B 3.50 is well above the median (2.00). Algo depth = 2.0, AI layer = 1.5, and transparency = 1.0. That combination signals a platform where AI is not cosmetic; it’s structurally central while still providing enough explainability to avoid pure black-box behavior.
In practice, this score indicates that Tickeron is designed to generate ideas, not merely visualize markets. Users who want “the system to propose trades and probabilities” will see immediate value; pure discretionary chartists won’t fully benefit.
| Metric | Calculation | Tickeron | High | Median | Low |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Automated Execution & Bot Reliability | Automation Path + Sophistication + Op Assurance | 3.50 | 4.50 | 2.50 | 1.50 |
| Automation Path | 0.5 none; 1 alerts; 1.5 webhook; 2 native execution | 1.50 | 2.00 | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| Strategy/Bot Sophistication | 0.5 simple → 2 “bot platform” depth | 1.50 | 2.00 | 1.50 | 1.00 |
| Transparency | 0.0 black-box; 0.5 some explanation; 1.0 clear methodology + validation artifacts | 0.50 | 5.00 | 2.00 | 1.00 |
| AI & Algo Index Test Winners | TrendSpider 5.00 | Trade Ideas 4.50 |
Tickeron suits someone who wants to examine ready-made AI ideas and model-based strategies. It offers another route into systematic research without first designing a custom model.
My main buying advice is to select a particular product and understand its function. A pattern notification, a model portfolio, a simulated agent, and a broker-connected service may all appear under AI-related terminology, but they do not provide the same experience.
Firstly, they use a database of technical analysis patterns to search the stock market for stocks that match those price patterns using their pattern search engine. Of course, each detected pattern has a backtested track record of success, and this pattern’s success is factored into the prediction using their Trend Prediction Engine.
Tikeron AI Bot Performance
Tickeron is the only AI software on this list (apart from Trade Ideas) that shares its track record of success. Of the 34 AI Trading Bots I looked at, only 2 reported less than a 30% annualized gain; the other AI Bots reported gains ranging from 40% to 169%, as shown in the image below. Tickeron claims impressive returns and audits all returns trade by trade.
Tickeron shared its AI algorithm’s performance by providing a fully audited track record of every stock Bot under management. Before purchasing a strategy, you can view its full performance summary, trade amounts, percentage of profitable trades, Sharpe ratio, and trade duration.
AI Stock Picks & Portfolios
Tickeron uses its artificial intelligence engine to provide specific stock picks. The algorithm can also be run on a specific index or watchlist to generate trading opportunities for your selected stocks. Tickeron also offers innovative portfolios that use AI to build portfolios with characteristics such as diversification and high returns. One specific AI stock asset allocation is “GROWING BIG DATA & CREATING BLOCKCHAINS PASSIVE,” which selects the best mix of AI stocks and blockchain companies.
Having tested Tickeron, I have to say it’s a very professional, sophisticated, and easy-to-use stock market AI software that delivers results. Tickeron is well worth trying.
What I Dislike: Backtesting 1.88
The published backtesting score is substantially weaker than those of the dedicated strategy-development platforms. That matters if you want to build and stress-test your own rules rather than evaluate a provider’s ideas.
I would also examine performance claims carefully. Establish whether a displayed record is simulated, backtested, or live, what costs it includes, and whether you are seeing the complete history. A vendor’s trade log can be informative without constituting an independent audit.
My recommendation: Consider Tickeron for a clearly defined model or signal service. Verify the module, subscription, and execution arrangement individually rather than assuming that a single plan includes all AI capabilities.
Read the Tickeron lab test and limitations
3 New AI Tools Evaluated (Sept. 2026)
The following tools can contribute to an AI-assisted workflow. I have evaluated their documented capabilities for this article, but they have not completed the LST lab assessment used for the main comparison. They therefore receive no LST star rating here.
SignalStack is an AI webhook-based automation tool that converts charting software like TradingView, TrendSpider, Schwab, and TradeStation into automated trading bots. This enables traders to automate and react quickly and accurately to market conditions without manually monitoring the markets all day.
SignalStack works with any software that can generate Webhook alerts, enabling traders to easily execute high-probability trading opportunities.
SignalStack: Connecting Trading Alerts to Brokerage Orders
SignalStack connects supported alert sources with supported brokerage accounts. The strategy supplies an instruction, and SignalStack translates the correctly configured message into a supported order.
A practical example is a TradingView or TrendSpider strategy that sends an entry alert to SignalStack. The execution bridge then routes the order to the connected broker. The same arrangement needs a defined exit process, correct quantities, and a way to monitor rejected or unexpected orders.
What appeals to me is that it addresses the gap between generating a signal and acting on it. You do not need to describe SignalStack as predictive AI to explain why it can be useful alongside an AI or rules-based strategy.
| Signal Stack Rating [how-we-test-?-white] | 4.5/5.0 |
|---|---|
| ⚡ AI Trading Features ? | Order Execution, Investing Bots, 99.99% Uptime |
| 🏆 Unique Features ? | Connects Charting Software to Brokers |
| 🎯 Best for | Stock, FX & Crypto Traders |
| ♲ Subscription | Per Signal |
| 💰 Price ? | $0.59-$1.49/signal |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser |
| 🎮 Trial | 25 Signals Free |
| 🌎 Region | Global |
If your current trading software lacks AI Bot trading capabilities, SignalStack could be the solution you’ve been seeking. SignalStack is an intelligent middleware platform that connects your trading software to your broker.
SignalStack offers a multitude of benefits that revolutionize your AI trading experience. Firstly, it facilitates efficient order execution, eliminating the need for manual oversight and ensuring swift placement of market orders.
Moreover, the platform offers 99.99% availability, customization, and flexibility, allowing investors to tailor their strategies to align with their individual investment goals and risk tolerance.
SignalStack is designed to process incoming signals from external systems seamlessly and swiftly convert them into live orders within a brokerage account. This groundbreaking technology was previously inaccessible to retail traders.
Unusual Whales: AI-Assisted Options-Flow Research
Unusual Whales adds a different perspective: investigating options activity and market positioning. Its Mr. Whale assistant provides conversational analysis and can set alerts or arrange a customized market brief. Its official MCP integration makes market-data tools available to compatible external assistants.
| ⚡ Unusual Whales Features | Real-Time Options Flow, Dark Pool Tracking, Congressional & Insider Trades, Native AI Market Analyst (“Mr. Whale”), Model Context Protocol (MCP) Integration, Market Maker Exposure (GEX), Volatility Dashboards |
| 🏆 Unique Features | MCP Server for AI Clients (Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor), AI Research Agents & Automations, Political & Insider Trade Tracking, Gamma Exposure (GEX) Heatmaps, Discord Bot Integration |
| 🎯 Best for | Active Options Traders, AI-Driven Financial Analysts, Retail Investors Tracking Institutional “Smart Money”, Quant & Dark Pool Researchers |
| ♲ Subscription | Monthly, Yearly |
| 💰 Price | Starts at $50/month (or $42/month billed annually); Pro tiers range from $63–$170/month |
| 🆓 Free | ✔ (Forever-free tier with delayed data access) |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser | iOS App | Android App | AI Workspaces (Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, Perplexity) |
| 🎮 Trial | 7-Day Trial on select API/AI plans (Delayed tier is permanently free) |
| ✂ Discount | Up to ~20% off with annual billing |
| 🌎 Region | Global (Focuses primarily on US Equity & Options Markets) |
What appeals to me: It gives an options-focused trader another way to investigate a potential setup. A question about unusual activity can prompt a closer examination of the relevant contracts and the underlying stock. This is a different research task from asking a general chatbot for a stock prediction.
Unusual Whales integrates natural language AI directly into options and equity analytics, allowing traders to query complex market metrics without writing code or manually parsing dense spreadsheets. Through its built-in AI assistant (“Mr. Whale”), users can ask natural-language questions such as “Show me today’s largest call sweeps over $1M” or “Summarize NVDA option flow heading into earnings” to receive instant, structured analysis. By converting millions of raw options trades, dark pool prints, and dealer positioning numbers into plain-English answers, the AI cuts down research time from hours to seconds.
Beyond a basic chatbot, the platform provides native Model Context Protocol (MCP) integration, turning external AI clients like Claude Desktop, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Cursor into custom financial workstations. With over 70 tools and 114 actions exposed through the MCP server, an AI assistant can natively call live endpoints for options flow, insider filings, short volume ratios, gamma exposure ladders, and prediction markets. This seamless connection allows traders to draft custom strategy screeners, backtest ideas, and analyze institutional flow, all within their preferred AI ecosystem.
The platform also features autonomous AI Automations, enabling market research agents to run 24/7 on autopilot. Users can configure AI research agents to compile scheduled ticker deep-dives, monitor live feeds for specific volume spikes, or draft personalized daily recaps delivered straight to their inbox. Rather than forcing traders to sit in front of monitors watching the tape all day, these autonomous agents continuously monitor the feeds and push proactive alerts or research briefs the moment significant institutional market shifts occur.
Ultimately, Unusual Whales’ AI suite bridges the historical gap between retail investors and institutional quantitative desks. By synthesizing dark pool data, political disclosures, and complex derivatives Greeks into readable reports, it prevents information overload and gives traders clear, actionable signals. Whether identifying short squeezes, tracking “smart money” flow, or evaluating market-maker hedging risks, the AI acts as a 24/7 financial analyst, helping traders make faster, data-backed decisions.
Interactive Brokers: AI Connected to Your Actual Portfolio
Interactive Brokers combines brokerage services with tools for inspecting account information. Ask IBKR answers portfolio questions, while IBot provides natural-language access to platform functions. These are separate from the broker’s external AI connections.
Its official MCP integration lets compatible assistants work with authorized account information and generate trade instructions. The documented workflow then requires the user to review and submit the order through the AI Instructions tab in an IBKR platform. I would not present that as unattended chatbot trading.
Connectivity: Chatbot: Ask IBKR; IBot supports natural-language commands. Webhooks: possible through a third-party execution bridge. Official MCP server: available.
| ⚡ Interactive Brokers Features | Global Multi-Asset Execution (Stocks, Options, Futures, FX, Bonds, Crypto), Trader Workstation (TWS) & IBKR Desktop, PortfolioAnalyst, Algorithmic Order Types, Direct Market Access |
| 🏆 Unique Features | Agentic AI Integrations (Claude, ChatGPT, Grok), AI-Powered Stock Screeners (70,000+ global stocks), “Ask IBKR” / IBot, AI News Summaries, Human-in-the-Loop “AI Instructions” Approval Workflow |
| 🎯 Best for | Active & Advanced Traders, Institutional Investors, Global Multi-Asset Investors, Tech-Savvy Retail Traders using LLMs |
| ♲ Subscription | No monthly platform fee (IBKR Lite or IBKR Pro pricing models) |
| 💰 Price | $0 commissions on US Stocks/ETFs (IBKR Lite) or low per-share pricing ($0.005/share, IBKR Pro); AI tools included at no extra cost |
| 🆓 Free | ✔ (Free simulated paper trading account available; AI features free for account holders) |
| 💻 OS | Web Browser | Windows | macOS | iOS | Android | Third-Party AI Apps (ChatGPT, Claude, Grok) |
| 🎮 Trial | Yes, Free Simulated Paper Trading Account |
| ✂ Discount | Margin interest discounts for high cash/equity balances; $0 stock commissions on IBKR Lite |
| 🌎 Region | Global (Access to 150+ markets across 34 countries and 27 currencies) |
Interactive Brokers (IBKR) has expanded its suite of agentic trading tools by enabling direct integrations with external AI models like ChatGPT, Claude, and Grok. Account holders can securely link their IBKR accounts to their preferred AI platform without sharing passwords or API keys. Once connected, traders can query their portfolio using natural language (e.g., “Which of my holdings have an RSI above 70?”) or ask the AI to draft multi-leg order instructions for complex products including equities, ETFs, options, and futures contracts.
Within its native platforms, IBKR incorporates several built-in AI tools designed to streamline market research. The AI Screener parses natural language prompts—such as “Find small-cap tech stocks with high free cash flow”—to filter through over 70,000 global equities. Additionally, AI News Summaries automatically synthesize market news into personalized recaps tailored to a trader’s watchlists. At the same time “Connections” graphs map out relationships between companies, sector ETFs, and derivatives to reveal hidden market exposure.
However, the tool setup comes with notable downsides. LLMs can hallucinate or misinterpret nuanced derivative parameters—such as option expiration cycles or futures delivery months—thereby requiring manual verification of every staged order. Furthermore, relying on third-party LLMs introduces API latency risks during peak market volatility. At the same time, IBKR’s historically steep interface learning curve can make reviewing complex AI-generated order instructions overwhelming for beginner retail traders.
What appeals to me: Portfolio-aware questions can be more useful than generic market commentary. For example, I would ask how holdings overlap, which exposures dominate an account, or what changed in recent transactions, then verify the answer against the account records.
For webhook automation, SignalStack documents an IBKR connection. That is a separate execution route from IBKR’s conversational AI workflow. An API, an MCP server, and a webhook receiver should not be treated as interchangeable features.
What Does an AI Trading Setup Really Cost?
Compare the cost of the workflow you intend to use, including the plan that unlocks the advertised feature. A low entry price is not helpful if the AI tool you want sits in another subscription.
| Tool | Access to check before subscribing | Main budgeting consideration |
|---|---|---|
| TrendSpider | Current plan limits for models, testing, alerts, bots and Sidekick | Assistant usage extensions, execution capacity and required market data can add to the base price. |
| Trade Ideas | Premium/Apex for Holly and its associated advanced features | Standard/Core is cheaper but does not include the same AI offering. |
| Tickeron | The exact model, agent or signal module you want | Check what that subscription includes and whether the advertised results are simulated. |
| TradingView | Essential or above for official MCP access; trials excluded | Check external assistant access, alert limits, execution services and exchange data. |
| Seeking Alpha | Exact access to Ask SA, Virtual Analyst Reports and Earnings Call Insights | PRO and Premium feature access differ; verify the tool you want before purchasing. |
| MetaStock | The appropriate product edition and data service | Compare the complete software-and-data package. |
| SignalStack | Supported broker and monthly executed-order allowance | Allow for entries, exits and the broker’s own charges. |
| Unusual Whales | Mr. Whale access, alerts and API/MCP entitlement | Do not assume the website subscription includes every data integration. |
| Interactive Brokers | Eligible account, AI access and required permissions | Check market data subscriptions, brokerage charges, and any external assistant costs. |
For Trade Ideas, compare the annual payment with 12 monthly payments for the plan that includes Holly. For TrendSpider, check Sidekick message allowances and model or bot capacity. For Seeking Alpha, establish whether you need the PRO assistant or the research features included with Premium.
MCP access can also involve two subscriptions: the data platform and the external assistant. A webhook workflow can involve a platform, an execution bridge, and a broker. Compare the total cost of the complete process, including required data and taxes.
I keep seasonal offers and plan-by-plan calculations in the linked pricing guides. Compare the actual amount charged, the subscription duration, and the renewal terms; a promotional headline alone does not tell you the long-term cost.
Final Advice
My hands-on testing confirms that Trade Ideas, TrendSpider, TradingView, and Seeking Alpha are the clear leaders in AI stock trading algorithms and AI investing portfolios. Trade Ideas, TrendSpider, and TradingView are designed for stock trading, and all provide fully automated trading, while Seeking Alpha specializes in long-term investing.
If you are looking for AI stock software that automatically executes day trades based on alerts, then Trade Ideas is perfect. If you want to use AI stock charts for backtesting and stock chart pattern recognition, TrendSpider is ideal. For a global community and global data, TradingView is the best choice.
FAQ
What Is the Best AI Stock Trading Software?
My leading choice for AI strategy development is TrendSpider. Trade Ideas suits US stock day-trading signals, TradingView combines charting with MCP-connected AI research, and Seeking Alpha suits fundamental research. Choose the task you need to improve.
Can AI Trading Software Place Trades Automatically?
Some configurations can, but AI analysis and order execution are separate functions. Confirm the exact product, broker connection, platform requirements, and settings. Sidekick analysis, a TradingView alert, and a simulated trading agent should not be assumed to place live orders simply because they appear in a trading platform.
Is There Free AI Stock Trading Software?
No, AI costs money. TradingView has a free plan, but it is not equivalent to a complete AI trading service. SignalStack has a small free execution allowance, but it does not generate AI signals. Check the specific capability, usage allowance, and trial terms rather than the word “free.”
Does TradingView Have an AI Chatbot and MCP Server?
Yes, TradingView has a new AI chatbot and an official MCP server. The MCP server connects TradingView functions to an external AI assistant for research conversations and supported platform actions. It is available in public beta to Essential and higher-paid plans, excluding trials.
What Is the Difference Between a Webhook and an MCP Server?
A webhook sends a message when something happens, such as a trading alert triggering. An MCP server allows an AI assistant to request data or invoke supported functions. Neither feature, by itself, proves that a platform can execute brokerage orders. Check the specific tools and permissions.
Can Seeking Alpha’s AI Trade for Me?
No, Seeking Alpha’s AI tools support research and analysis, but not trading. Treat it as a research source for decisions you evaluate and execute through a suitable broker.
Are AI Trading Bots Profitable?
In all my testing, the only bot proven to be profitable is Holly AI, provided by Trade Ideas.
Should a Beginner Start With an Automated Trading Bot?
No, I would start by learning how to evaluate a setup and manage the workflow in a simulated environment. If you cannot explain why a trade should open, what would close it, and how much it could lose, automating those decisions makes the process harder to supervise.
27/09/2026 – Update to Seeking AI Rating with ChatBot (Copilot) & Virtual Analyst Assistant. Updated TradingView Rating with Chatbox & MCP server additions. Added new contenders, Unusual Whales, and IB AI Chat.
Hi Locolady, thanks for your input. I have now updated the article to reflect the changes. Staying on top of all the changes in all the trading software is challenging and I appreciate your feeback. Barry
The date on your article is April 30, 2024, yet reading comments, they date from 2021. That’s a little confusing. I bring it up, because the section on Trade Ideas is now outdated… Holly no longer auto-trades, and according to Chris Varley at TI, Holly auto trading was discontinued 17 months ago. That part of your article is now outdated, and shouldn’t show a current date.
Hi Jim, wow what a question. How about https://www.algotrader.com/ this might suit your needs. Let me know how you get on with your research.
Barry
Hi,
Great article. But none of the software quite fit my needs. From my perspective I have say algorithms helping to determine entry/exit etc. for a symbol or a group of dependent symbols. As well as flexible entry/exit criteria, like risk/reward metrics and so on. I can back test on my brocker’s software. What I want is an AI/machine-learning platform to automate trading that a:- has access to realtime data over any timeperiod. b:-allows me to simply program my algos in, process realtime market data (tick/minute/5min/4hour etc); generating trade entry and exit signals. c:- has an API compatible with my (ticker/ETF/Futures/Crypto) brokers to execute the trades, d:-has the ability to be replicated for each stock or account running in parallel (cloud/server scalable).
From the article I would losely compare (a/b) “AI Trading Signals”. and (c) with “Automated Trading Bots”. They all seem to lack the flexibility I am looking for. Is there a more bare-bones AI out there reasonably easy to adapt to trading. Or does say “Trade Ideas” have more flexibility in the algorithim definitions/design then what the literature suggests.
Any input is greatly appreciated.
Hi Bernd, I forwarded your question to my contacts at Trade Ideas, here is the answer to your question from Chris Varley @ trade-ideas.
Hello,
While I do not have the exact figures on how IB structures commissions (one of the two brokers we directly link to) From my experience with them and the commissions structure I selected with them it works out to be about $1 in and $1 dollar out per trade when taking 150-300 shares per trade, so realistically those commissions should not bare much affect on your trades. They will add 1-2 cents at most to the cost basis per share.
Example: you buy 200 shares market at $15 your cost basis is $15.01 When buying more shares the commission goes up a bit the cost basis will remain relatively the same
You can have a look at IB’s page for the different commission structures https://www.trade-ideas.com/ibkr
You would have to pay IB for live data if you are looking at automation with Holly and that costs about $4.50 a month for one plan, or you can take a $10 plan and have the fee waved if you have $30 in commissions a month.
Etrade which is the other broker we link to has no commissions or data fees.
If you are only looking to manually trade then you can go with any broker you choose
As for the question what you should be making in a year- There really is no way to know, aside from commissions there are other factors involved. There is slippage, HTB stocks or No Borrow stock, and while these things do not happen often they play a role.
This here is a video I did on Holly in simulation with some realistic thoughts behind it>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vQ6wFHvbT80&list=PLrjuUll3PvdJUKmXXA8wqtaSzc7JndiHY&index=11&t=10s
I would also like to invite you to our daily 12pm Est Q&A session and/or our 3:30pm Est Q&A session were we can address any other questions. Here is that link https://www.liberatedstocktrader.com/trade-ideas-trading-room This room goes Live at 9am Est with Barrie but has the live Q&A’s at the aforementioned times
Best,
Chris Varley
Hello Liberated stock trader,
I read your review on AI-systems and found it very useful. I am testing the trade-ideas Holly-AI at the moment. My problem is: the commissions… Although low (1$ per 100 shares or 5$ per 1000), they minimize the profit. You wrote that one could make about 20% a year. I have all three segments running, assuming 10.000 $ of buy and sell together every day invested ( and flattened), how much should I be making in one year? 10.000 x 0.2 = 2000? Minus commissions? That would not even cover the costs?! Could you explain? If I wanted to invest more four or five real bad days in a row would wipe out my account, wouldnt they?
Thanks in advance… A “trader”
Hi Marvin, simply select the software you want to try and go from there.
How can I get started and how much the cost
Hi Phillip, thanks for the question.
The best that I know of is Trade Ideas, they have a fully automated solution based on their AI engine. https://www.liberatedstocktrader.com/trade-ideas
Barry
Do you have any fully automated trading programs that trade themselves? Thanks.
Phillip